/// <summary>
/// Unfortunately, we were not able to ship the dataset for this chapter,
/// so the code will not run.
/// It is still the correct code that was used to produce the result for the chapter.
///
/// Defines the entry point of the application.
/// The first argument, if present, sets the folder to save the output artifacts in.
/// </summary>
public static void Main(string[] args)
{
InitializeUI();
Outputter outputter = Outputter.GetOutputter(Contents.ChapterName);
// We expect the data in a folder near the repository.
const string dataPath = @"../../../../../../HarnessingTheCrowdData";
try
{
// Parameters of the experiment to run.
// Modify if you want to run only some of the models, try different numbers of communities, etc.
var experimentParameters = new ExperimentParameters
{
ExperimentNamePrefix = string.Empty,
RandomSeed = 12347,
FractionGoldLabelsReservedForTraining = 0.3,
UseOnlyTweetsWithGoldLabels = false,
UseGoldLabelsInTraining = false,
NumberOfTrainingTweets = 10000,
NumDataSizes = 10,
NumberOfCommunitiesSweep = new[] { 1, 2, 3 },
VocabularyThreshold = 10,
ModelTypes = ModelTypes.MajorityVote
| ModelTypes.HonestWorker
| ModelTypes.BiasedWorker
| ModelTypes.BiasedCommunity
| ModelTypes.BiasedCommunityWords
};
RunExperiments(outputter, experimentParameters, dataPath);
}
catch (Exception e)
{
Console.WriteLine($"\nAn unhandled exception was thrown:\n{e}");
}
finally
{
if (args.Length == 1)
{
Console.WriteLine("\n\nSaving outputs...");
outputter.SaveOutputAsProducedFlattening(args[0]);
Console.WriteLine("Done saving.");
}
}
}
RunSweep(
CrowdDataWithText[] trainingDataSets,
CrowdDataWithText validationDataSet,
ModelBase model,
CorpusInformation corpusInformation,
Func <CrowdDataMapping, ModelBase, ModelRunnerBase, ModelRunnerBase> runnerCreator,
Func <ModelRunnerBase, Dictionary <string, object> > trainingResultGetter,
Func <ModelRunnerBase, Dictionary <string, object>, Dictionary <string, object> > validationResultGetter,
ExperimentParameters experimentParameters,
CrowdDataWithText validationDataSetNoLabels = null,
List <ModelRunnerBase> previousTrainingRunners = null,
int numIterations = 200,
Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, object> > resultStorage = null)
{
var allResultsForThisModel = resultStorage ?? new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, object> >();
var trainingRunners = new List <ModelRunnerBase>();
const int NumIterationsForValidation = 5;
for (var i = 0; i < trainingDataSets.Length; i++)
{
var currentModelName =
$"{model.Name}_{i}"; // Chart code assumes suffix of dash then number for ordering chart points
var trainingData = trainingDataSets[i];
var trainingMapping = new CrowdDataWithTextMapping(
trainingData,
LabelValuesToString,
corpusInformation);
var trainingRunner = runnerCreator.Invoke(trainingMapping, model, previousTrainingRunners?[i]);
trainingRunners.Add(trainingRunner);
Rand.Restart(experimentParameters.RandomSeed);
RunModel(trainingRunner, currentModelName + "_Training", numIterations,
experimentParameters.UseGoldLabelsInTraining);
var trainingResults = trainingResultGetter?.Invoke(trainingRunner) ?? new Dictionary <string, object>();
trainingResults[ErrorsKey] = trainingRunner.GetErrors();
trainingResults[WorkerMetricsKey] = GetWorkerMetrics(trainingRunner.DataMapping.Data, trainingRunner, experimentParameters.MaximumNumberWorkers);
var currentResults =
new Dictionary <string, object> {
[TrainingKey] = trainingResults
};
var validationMapping = new CrowdDataWithTextMapping(
validationDataSet,
LabelValuesToString,
corpusInformation);
var validationRunner = runnerCreator.Invoke(validationMapping, model, trainingRunner);
Rand.Restart(experimentParameters.RandomSeed);
var validationMetrics = RunModel(validationRunner, currentModelName + "_Validation",
NumIterationsForValidation, false);
foreach (var prediction in validationRunner.Posteriors.TrueLabel)
{
Console.WriteLine(prediction);
}
var validationResults = validationResultGetter.Invoke(validationRunner, validationMetrics);
validationResults[ErrorsKey] = validationRunner.GetErrors();
validationResults[WorkerMetricsKey] = GetWorkerMetrics(validationRunner.DataMapping.Data,
validationRunner, experimentParameters.MaximumNumberWorkers);
currentResults[ValidationKey] = validationResults;
if (validationDataSetNoLabels != null)
{
var validationMappingNoLabels = new CrowdDataWithTextMapping(
validationDataSetNoLabels,
LabelValuesToString,
corpusInformation);
var validationNoLabelsRunner =
runnerCreator.Invoke(validationMappingNoLabels, model, trainingRunner);
Rand.Restart(experimentParameters.RandomSeed);
var validationMetricsNoLabels = RunModel(validationNoLabelsRunner,
currentModelName + "_ValidationNoLabels", NumIterationsForValidation, false);
currentResults[ValidationNoLabelsKey] =
validationResultGetter.Invoke(validationNoLabelsRunner, validationMetricsNoLabels);
}
allResultsForThisModel[$"TrainingPercent_{Math.Min((i + 1) * 100 / trainingDataSets.Length, 100)}"] =
currentResults;
}
return(allResultsForThisModel, trainingRunners);
}
public static void RunExperiments(Outputter outputter, ExperimentParameters experimentParameters, string dataPath)
{
var engine = new InferenceEngine(new ExpectationPropagation())
{
ShowFactorGraph = false,
ShowWarnings = true,
ShowProgress = false
};
// Set engine flags
engine.Compiler.WriteSourceFiles = true;
engine.Compiler.UseParallelForLoops = false;
string labelsFileName = Path.Combine(dataPath, "HarnessingTheCrowdLabels.tsv");
string goldLabelsFileName = Path.Combine(dataPath, "HarnessingTheCrowdGoldLabels.tsv");
string textsFileName = Path.Combine(dataPath, "HarnessingTheCrowdTexts.tsv");
if (!File.Exists(labelsFileName) ||
!File.Exists(goldLabelsFileName) ||
!File.Exists(textsFileName))
{
throw new FileNotFoundException("Unfortunately, we were not able to ship the data necessary to run the code for this chapter.");
}
var crowdData = CrowdDataWithText.LoadData(
labelsFileName,
goldLabelsFileName,
textsFileName,
new HashSet <int>(LabelValuesToString.Keys));
Rand.Restart(experimentParameters.RandomSeed);
// Preparing the input data
var split = crowdData.SplitData(experimentParameters.FractionGoldLabelsReservedForTraining);
var fullTrainingData = split[CrowdData.Mode.Training];
var fullValidationData = split[CrowdData.Mode.Validation];
var trainingData = (CrowdDataWithText)fullTrainingData.LimitData(
maxNumTweets: experimentParameters.UseOnlyTweetsWithGoldLabels
? fullTrainingData.NumGoldTweets
: experimentParameters.NumberOfTrainingTweets,
randomSeed: experimentParameters.RandomSeed);
if (experimentParameters.UseBalancedTrainingSets)
{
trainingData = (CrowdDataWithText)fullTrainingData.LimitData(
maxNumTweets: experimentParameters.UseOnlyTweetsWithGoldLabels
? fullTrainingData.NumGoldTweets
: experimentParameters.NumberOfTrainingTweets,
balanceTweetsByLabel: true,
randomSeed: experimentParameters.RandomSeed);
}
var validationData = (CrowdDataWithText)fullValidationData.LimitData(
experimentParameters.NumberOfValidationJudgments,
randomSeed: experimentParameters.RandomSeed);
var validationDataWithNoWorkerLabels = (CrowdDataWithText)validationData.LimitData(maxNumWorkers: 0);
var trainingWorkerMetrics = GetWorkerMetrics(trainingData, null, experimentParameters.MaximumNumberWorkers);
var validationWorkerMetrics =
GetWorkerMetrics(validationData, null, experimentParameters.MaximumNumberWorkers);
var corpus = trainingData.TweetTexts.Values.Distinct().ToArray();
var corpusInformation = CorpusInformation.BuildCorpusInformation(
corpus,
experimentParameters.VocabularyThreshold);
var totalNumTrainingJudgments = trainingData.CrowdLabels.Count;
var numTrainingJudgments = Util.ArrayInit(
experimentParameters.NumDataSizes,
i => Math.Round(totalNumTrainingJudgments * (i + 1) / (double)experimentParameters.NumDataSizes));
var trainingDataSets = Util.ArrayInit(
experimentParameters.NumDataSizes,
i => (CrowdDataWithText)trainingData.LimitData((int)numTrainingJudgments[i],
randomSeed: experimentParameters.RandomSeed));
var trainingTweets = trainingData.Tweets;
var trainingCrowdWorkers = trainingData.Workers;
var validationTweets = validationData.Tweets;
var validationCrowdWorkers = validationData.Workers;
var allDataInfo = new Dictionary <string, object>
{
["Full training data"] = fullTrainingData,
["Full validation data"] = fullValidationData,
["Validation data"] = validationData,
["Training data"] = trainingData,
["Training data sets"] = trainingDataSets,
["Validation data set"] = validationData,
["Training set tweets"] = trainingTweets,
["Training set crowd workers"] = trainingCrowdWorkers,
["Validation set tweets"] = validationTweets,
["Validation set crowd workers"] = validationCrowdWorkers,
["CorpusInformation"] = corpusInformation
};
outputter.Out(allDataInfo, "Inputs");
WriteCrowdDataDetailsToConsole(fullTrainingData, "Full training data");
WriteCrowdDataDetailsToConsole(fullValidationData, "Full validation data");
WriteCrowdDataDetailsToConsole(trainingData, "Training set");
WriteCrowdDataDetailsToConsole(validationData, "Validation set");
var now = DateTime.Now;
var nowStr = $"{now.Year:D4}{now.Month:D2}{now.Day:D2}T{now.Hour:D2}{now.Minute:D2}{now.Second:D2}";
var experimentInfo = new Dictionary <string, object>
{
["Date"] = nowStr,
["Parameters"] = experimentParameters,
[$"Training {WorkerMetricsKey}"] = trainingWorkerMetrics,
[$"Validation {WorkerMetricsKey}"] = validationWorkerMetrics,
[$"Training {LabelCountHistogramKey}"] = GetWorkerLabelCountHistogram(trainingData),
[$"Validation {LabelCountHistogramKey}"] = GetWorkerLabelCountHistogram(validationData)
};
outputter.Out(experimentInfo, "Experiment");
// Data structures for comparing results
var metricsForPlots = new List <Metric> {
Metric.Accuracy, Metric.AverageLogProb
};
var metricsStripCharts = new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, PointWithBounds[]> >();
var metricsBarCharts = new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, double> >();
foreach (var metric in metricsForPlots)
{
var metricString = metric.ToString();
metricsStripCharts[metricString] = new Dictionary <string, PointWithBounds[]>();
metricsBarCharts[metricString] = new Dictionary <string, double>();
}
// Creates a snapshot of currently accumulated comparison metrics
Dictionary <string, object> getCurrentComparisonSnapshot()
{
var metricsStripChartsSnapshot =
new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, PointWithBounds[]> >();
var metricsBarChartsSnapshot =
new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, double> >();
foreach (var metric in metricsForPlots)
{
var metricString = metric.ToString();
metricsStripChartsSnapshot[metricString] = new Dictionary <string, PointWithBounds[]>(metricsStripCharts[metricString]);
metricsBarChartsSnapshot[metricString] = new Dictionary <string, double>(metricsBarCharts[metricString]);
}
return(new Dictionary <string, object>
{
["Strip Charts"] = metricsStripChartsSnapshot,
["Bar Charts"] = metricsBarChartsSnapshot
});
}
// Running models as specified in experiment parameters
bool section2Started = false;
Dictionary <string, object> section2Comparison = null;
if ((experimentParameters.ModelTypes & ModelTypes.MajorityVote) != 0)
{
Console.WriteLine($"\n{Contents.S2TryingOutTheWorkerModel.NumberedName}\n");
section2Started = true;
var accuracyString = Metric.Accuracy.ToString();
var majorityVoteString = "Majority Vote";
var majorityVoteMetrics = RunMajorityVoteModel(validationData, majorityVoteString);
outputter.Out(majorityVoteMetrics, Contents.S2TryingOutTheWorkerModel.NumberedName, majorityVoteString);
metricsStripCharts[accuracyString][majorityVoteString] = GetChartPointsForMetric(
Enumerable.Repeat(majorityVoteMetrics, trainingDataSets.Length).ToList(),
Metric.Accuracy.ToString(),
numTrainingJudgments);
metricsBarCharts[accuracyString][majorityVoteString] =
metricsStripCharts[accuracyString][majorityVoteString].Last().Y;
section2Comparison = getCurrentComparisonSnapshot();
outputter.Out(section2Comparison, Contents.S2TryingOutTheWorkerModel.NumberedName, "Comparison");
}
if ((experimentParameters.ModelTypes & ModelTypes.HonestWorker) != 0)
{
if (!section2Started)
{
Console.WriteLine($"\n{Contents.S2TryingOutTheWorkerModel.NumberedName}\n");
}
var currentModel = new HonestWorkerModel(engine);
var honestWorkerMetrics = new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, object> >();
outputter.Out(honestWorkerMetrics, Contents.S2TryingOutTheWorkerModel.NumberedName, currentModel.Name);
honestWorkerMetrics = RunSweep(
trainingDataSets,
validationData,
currentModel,
corpusInformation,
(map, model, runner) => new HonestWorkerRunner(map, (HonestWorkerModel)model, runner),
GetHonestWorkerTrainingResults,
(runner, metrics) =>
GetHonestWorkerValidationResults(runner, metrics, experimentParameters.MaximumNumberWorkers),
experimentParameters,
resultStorage: honestWorkerMetrics).Results;
foreach (var metric in metricsForPlots)
{
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
GetChartPointsForMetric(honestWorkerMetrics, metric, numTrainingJudgments);
metricsBarCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name].Last().Y;
}
section2Comparison = getCurrentComparisonSnapshot();
outputter.Out(section2Comparison, Contents.S2TryingOutTheWorkerModel.NumberedName, "Comparison");
}
if ((experimentParameters.ModelTypes & ModelTypes.BiasedWorker) != 0)
{
Console.WriteLine($"\n{Contents.S3CorrectingForWorkerBiases.NumberedName}\n");
var currentModel = new BiasedWorkerModel(engine);
var biasedWorkerMetrics = new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, object> >();
outputter.Out(biasedWorkerMetrics, Contents.S3CorrectingForWorkerBiases.NumberedName, currentModel.Name);
biasedWorkerMetrics = RunSweep(
trainingDataSets,
validationData,
currentModel,
corpusInformation,
(map, model, runner) => new BiasedWorkerModelRunner(map, (BiasedWorkerModel)model, runner),
runner => GetBiasedWorkerTrainingResults(runner, experimentParameters.MaximumNumberWorkers),
GetValidationResults,
experimentParameters,
resultStorage: biasedWorkerMetrics).Results;
foreach (var metric in metricsForPlots)
{
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
GetChartPointsForMetric(biasedWorkerMetrics, metric, numTrainingJudgments);
metricsBarCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name].Last().Y;
}
outputter.Out(getCurrentComparisonSnapshot(), Contents.S3CorrectingForWorkerBiases.NumberedName, "Comparison");
}
if ((experimentParameters.ModelTypes & ModelTypes.BiasedCommunity) != 0)
{
Console.WriteLine($"\n{Contents.S4CommunitiesOfWorkers.NumberedName}\n");
engine.Algorithm = new VariationalMessagePassing();
foreach (int numCommunities in experimentParameters.NumberOfCommunitiesSweep)
{
var currentModel = new BiasedCommunityModel(engine)
{
NumberOfCommunities = numCommunities
};
var result = new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, object> >();
outputter.Out(result, Contents.S4CommunitiesOfWorkers.NumberedName, currentModel.Name);
result = RunSweep(
trainingDataSets,
validationData,
currentModel,
corpusInformation,
(map, model, runner) => new BiasedCommunityModelRunner(
map,
(BiasedCommunityModel)model,
runner),
GetBiasedCommunityTrainingResults,
GetValidationResults,
experimentParameters,
resultStorage: result).Results;
foreach (var metric in metricsForPlots)
{
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
GetChartPointsForMetric(result, metric, numTrainingJudgments);
metricsBarCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name].Last().Y;
}
}
outputter.Out(getCurrentComparisonSnapshot(), Contents.S4CommunitiesOfWorkers.NumberedName, "Comparison");
}
if ((experimentParameters.ModelTypes & ModelTypes.BiasedCommunityWords) != 0)
{
Console.WriteLine($"\n{Contents.S5MakingUseOfTheTweets.NumberedName}\n");
// VMP is an order of magnitude faster than EP here, while producing almost the same result
engine.Algorithm = new VariationalMessagePassing();
foreach (int numCommunities in experimentParameters.NumberOfCommunitiesSweep)
{
var currentModel = new BiasedCommunityWordsModel(engine)
{
NumberOfCommunities = numCommunities
};
var result = new Dictionary <string, Dictionary <string, object> >();
outputter.Out(result, Contents.S5MakingUseOfTheTweets.NumberedName, currentModel.Name);
result = RunSweep(
trainingDataSets,
validationData,
currentModel,
corpusInformation,
(map, model, runner) => new BiasedCommunityWordsRunner(
(CrowdDataWithTextMapping)map,
(BiasedCommunityWordsModel)model,
runner),
GetBiasedCommunityWordsRunnerResults,
GetValidationResults,
experimentParameters,
validationDataWithNoWorkerLabels,
null,
50,
resultStorage: result).Results;
foreach (var metric in metricsForPlots)
{
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
GetChartPointsForMetric(result, metric, numTrainingJudgments);
metricsBarCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name] =
metricsStripCharts[metric.ToString()][currentModel.Name].Last().Y;
}
}
outputter.Out(getCurrentComparisonSnapshot(), Contents.S5MakingUseOfTheTweets.NumberedName, "Comparison");
}
Console.WriteLine("\nCompleted all experiments.");
}
