public override bool CompareTo(IMensRea criminalIntent, params ILegalPerson[] persons)
{
var isRequiredIntent = criminalIntent is Negligently ||
criminalIntent is Recklessly ||
criminalIntent is GeneralIntent;
if (!isRequiredIntent)
{
AddReasonEntry($"{nameof(ManslaughterInvoluntary)} is expected {nameof(Recklessly)} " +
$"or {nameof(Negligently)} intent, not {criminalIntent?.GetType().Name}");
return(false);
}
return(true);
}
public bool CompareTo(IMensRea criminalIntent, params ILegalPerson[] persons)
{
var validIntent = _information is MilitaryActivities
? new[] { typeof(Purposely), typeof(SpecificIntent) }
: new[] { typeof(Purposely), typeof(SpecificIntent), typeof(Knowingly), typeof(GeneralIntent) };
if (validIntent.All(i => criminalIntent.GetType() != i))
{
var nms = string.Join(", ", validIntent.Select(t => t.Name));
AddReasonEntry($"{nameof(Espionage)} for {_information.GetCategory()} requires intent {nms}");
return(false);
}
return(true);
}
public override bool CompareTo(IMensRea criminalIntent, params ILegalPerson[] persons)
{
var adequateProvation = criminalIntent as AdequateProvocation;
var defendant = this.Defendant(persons);
if (adequateProvation != null && defendant != null && adequateProvation.IsValid(defendant))
{
return(true);
}
AddReasonEntry($"{nameof(ManslaughterVoluntary)} is a redux of {nameof(Murder)} " +
$"by means of {nameof(AdequateProvocation)} intent, " +
$"which {criminalIntent?.GetType().Name} is not");
return(false);
}
public bool CompareTo(IMensRea criminalIntent, params ILegalPerson[] persons)
{
var validIntent = new[]
{
typeof(SpecificIntent), typeof(Purposely), typeof(GeneralIntent), typeof(Knowingly), typeof(Negligently)
};
if (validIntent.All(t => t != criminalIntent.GetType()))
{
var nms = string.Join(", ", validIntent.Select(t => t.Name));
AddReasonEntry($"{nameof(Sabotage)} requires intent of {nms}");
return(false);
}
return(true);
}
public bool CompareTo(IMensRea criminalIntent, params ILegalPerson[] persons)
{
var defendant = persons.Defendant();
if (defendant == null)
{
return(false);
}
var isByViolence = IsByViolence(defendant);
var validIntent = isByViolence
? new[] { typeof(Purposely), typeof(SpecificIntent) }
: new[] { typeof(Knowingly), typeof(GeneralIntent) };
//Cramer v. U.S., 1945, different intent based on which predicate
if (validIntent.All(i => criminalIntent.GetType() != i))
{
var nms = string.Join(", ", validIntent.Select(t => t.Name));
AddReasonEntry($"{nameof(Treason)} for {nameof(IsByViolence)} as {isByViolence} requires intent {nms}");
return(false);
}
return(true);
}
public bool CompareTo(IMensRea criminalIntent, params ILegalPerson[] persons)
{
var defendant = persons.Defendant();
if (defendant == null)
{
return(false);
}
//Yates v. U.S., 354 U.S. 298 (1957), different intent based on which predicate
var inWrittenForm = IsInWrittenForm(defendant);
var validIntent = inWrittenForm
? new[] { typeof(Purposely), typeof(SpecificIntent) }
: new[] { typeof(Knowingly), typeof(GeneralIntent) };
if (validIntent.All(i => criminalIntent.GetType() != i))
{
var nms = string.Join(", ", validIntent.Select(t => t.Name));
AddReasonEntry($"{nameof(Sedition)} for {nameof(IsInWrittenForm)} as {inWrittenForm} requires intent {nms}");
return(false);
}
return(true);
}