public void MeanSquaredRandomTest()
        {
            Python.Initialize();
            Chainer.Initialize();

            int batchCount = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 5);
            int ch         = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 5);
            int width      = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 16);
            int height     = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 16);

            Real[,,,] inputA = (Real[, , , ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { batchCount, ch, height, width });
            Real[,,,] inputB = (Real[, , , ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { batchCount, ch, height, width });

            for (int i = 0; i < inputB.GetLength(0); i++)
            {
                for (int j = 0; j < inputB.GetLength(1); j++)
                {
                    for (int k = 0; k < inputB.GetLength(2); k++)
                    {
                        for (int l = 0; l < inputB.GetLength(3); l++)
                        {
                            inputB[i, j, k, l] *= 3.1415;
                        }
                    }
                }
            }

            //chainer
            NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real> cMeanSquaredError = new NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real>();

            Variable <Real> cX = new Variable <Real>(Real.ToBaseNdArray(inputA));
            Variable <Real> cY = new Variable <Real>(Real.ToBaseNdArray(inputB));

            Variable <Real> cZ = cMeanSquaredError.Forward(cX, cY);

            cZ.Backward();

            Real[] cXgrad = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, , , ])cX.Grad);

            //KelpNet
            KelpNet.MeanSquaredError meanSquaredError = new KelpNet.MeanSquaredError();

            NdArray x = new NdArray(Real.ToRealArray(inputA), new[] { ch, height, width }, batchCount);
            NdArray y = new NdArray(Real.ToRealArray(inputB), new[] { ch, height, width }, batchCount);

            //KelpNetはBackwaward側のみEvaluateで実行される
            NdArray z = meanSquaredError.Evaluate(x, y);


            //許容範囲を算出(内部の割引順が違うため誤差が大きい)
            double delta = 0.001;

            //Loss
            Assert.AreEqual(cZ.Data[0], z.Data[0], delta);

            //x.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad.Length, x.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < x.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad[i], x.Grad[i], delta);
            }
        }
        public void MeanSquaredRandomTest()
        {
            Python.Initialize();
            Chainer.Initialize();

            int batchCount = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 5);
            int ch         = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 5);
            int width      = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 16);
            int height     = Mother.Dice.Next(1, 16);

            Real[,,,] inputA = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, , , ]>(batchCount, ch, height, width);
            Real[,,,] inputB = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, , , ]>(batchCount, ch, height, width);

            for (int i = 0; i < inputB.GetLength(0); i++)
            {
                for (int j = 0; j < inputB.GetLength(1); j++)
                {
                    for (int k = 0; k < inputB.GetLength(2); k++)
                    {
                        for (int l = 0; l < inputB.GetLength(3); l++)
                        {
                            inputB[i, j, k, l] *= (Real)3.1415f;
                        }
                    }
                }
            }

            //chainer
            NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real> cMeanSquaredError = new NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real>();

            Variable <Real> cX = new Variable <Real>(inputA);
            Variable <Real> cY = new Variable <Real>(inputB);

            Variable <Real> cZ = cMeanSquaredError.Forward(cX, cY);

            cZ.Backward();

            Real[] cXgrad = ((Real[, , , ])cX.Grad).Flatten();

            //KelpNet
            KelpNet.MeanSquaredError <Real> meanSquaredError = new KelpNet.MeanSquaredError <Real>();

            NdArray <Real> x = new NdArray <Real>(inputA, asBatch: true);
            NdArray <Real> y = new NdArray <Real>(inputB, asBatch: true);

            //KelpNetはBackwaward側のみEvaluateで実行される
            NdArray <Real> z = meanSquaredError.Evaluate(x, y);


            //許容範囲を算出(内部の割引順が違うため誤差が大きい)
            Real delta = 0.001f;

            //Loss
            Assert.AreEqual(cZ.Data[0], z.Data[0], delta);

            //x.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad.Length, x.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < x.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad[i], x.Grad[i], delta);
            }
        }
        public void RnnLSTMRandomTest()
        {
            Python.Initialize();
            Chainer.Initialize();

            Real[,] input = { { 1.0 }, { 3.0 }, { 5.0 }, { 7.0 }, { 9.0 } };
            Real[,] teach = { { 3.0 }, { 5.0 }, { 7.0 }, { 9.0 }, { 11.0 } };

            Real[,] input2 = { { 3.0 }, { 5.0 }, { 7.0 }, { 9.0 }, { 11.0 } };
            Real[,] teach2 = { { 5.0 }, { 7.0 }, { 9.0 }, { 11.0 }, { 13.0 } };

            int outputCount = 1;
            int inputCount  = 1;
            int hiddenCount = 2;

            Real[,] upwardInit      = (Real[, ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { hiddenCount, hiddenCount });
            Real[,] lateralInit     = (Real[, ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { hiddenCount, hiddenCount });
            Real[,,] biasInit       = (Real[, , ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { 1, hiddenCount, 1 });
            Real[,,] forgetBiasInit = (Real[, , ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { 1, hiddenCount, 1 });

            //Chainer
            Real[,] w1 = (Real[, ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { hiddenCount, inputCount });
            Real[] b1 = Initializer.GetRealArray(hiddenCount);

            //Chainer
            NChainer.Linear <Real> cLinear1 = new NChainer.Linear <Real>(inputCount, hiddenCount, false, Real.ToBaseNdArray(w1), Real.ToBaseArray(b1));
            NChainer.LSTM <Real>   cLstm    = new NChainer.LSTM <Real>(hiddenCount, hiddenCount, Real.ToBaseNdArray(lateralInit), Real.ToBaseNdArray(upwardInit), Real.ToBaseNdArray(biasInit), Real.ToBaseNdArray(forgetBiasInit));

            Real[,] w2 = (Real[, ])Initializer.GetRealNdArray(new[] { outputCount, hiddenCount });
            Real[] b2 = Initializer.GetRealArray(outputCount);
            NChainer.Linear <Real> cLinear2 = new NChainer.Linear <Real>(hiddenCount, outputCount, false, Real.ToBaseNdArray(w2), Real.ToBaseArray(b2));

            Variable <Real> cX1  = new Variable <Real>(Real.ToBaseNdArray(input));
            Variable <Real> cY11 = cLinear1.Forward(cX1);
            Variable <Real> cY12 = cLstm.Forward(cY11);
            Variable <Real> cY13 = cLinear2.Forward(cY12);
            Variable <Real> cT   = new Variable <Real>(Real.ToBaseNdArray(teach));

            Variable <Real> cLoss = new NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real>().Forward(cY13, cT);

            cLoss.Backward();


            //KelpNet
            KelpNet.CL.Linear linear1 = new KelpNet.CL.Linear(inputCount, hiddenCount, false, w1, b1);
            KelpNet.LSTM      lstm    = new KelpNet.LSTM(hiddenCount, hiddenCount, lateralInit, upwardInit, biasInit, forgetBiasInit);
            KelpNet.CL.Linear linear2 = new KelpNet.CL.Linear(hiddenCount, outputCount, false, w2, b2);

            NdArray x1  = new NdArray(Real.ToRealArray(input), new[] { 1 }, 5);
            NdArray y11 = linear1.Forward(x1)[0];
            NdArray y12 = lstm.Forward(y11)[0];
            NdArray y13 = linear2.Forward(y12)[0];
            NdArray t   = new NdArray(Real.ToRealArray(teach), new[] { 1 }, 5);

            NdArray loss = new KelpNet.MeanSquaredError().Evaluate(y13, t);

            y13.Backward();

            Real[] cY11data = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cY11.Data);
            Real[] cY12data = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cY12.Data);
            Real[] cY13data = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cY13.Data);
            Real[] cXgrad   = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cX1.Grad);

            Real[] cupwardWGrad = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cLstm.upward.W.Grad);
            Real[] cupwardbGrad = (Real[])cLstm.upward.b.Grad;


            //許容範囲を設定
            double delta = 0.00001;

            //y11
            Assert.AreEqual(cY11data.Length, y11.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cY11data.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cY11data[i], y11.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y12
            Assert.AreEqual(cY12data.Length, y12.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cY12data.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cY12data[i], y12.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y13
            Assert.AreEqual(cY13data.Length, y13.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cY13data.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cY13data[i], y13.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //許容範囲を設定
            delta = 0.0001;

            //loss
            Assert.AreEqual(cLoss.Data[0], loss.Data[0], delta);

            //x.Grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad.Length, x1.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cXgrad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad[i], x1.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            Real[] cWgrad11 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cLinear1.W.Grad);
            Real[] cbgrad11 = (Real[])cLinear1.b.Grad;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad11.Length, linear1.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad11[i], linear1.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad11.Length, linear1.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad11[i], linear1.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            Real[] cWgrad12 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cLinear2.W.Grad);
            Real[] cbgrad12 = (Real[])cLinear2.b.Grad;


            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad12.Length, linear2.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad12[i], linear2.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad12.Length, linear2.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad12[i], linear2.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //W.grad
            int wLen = lstm.upward.Weight.Grad.Length;

            Assert.AreEqual(cupwardWGrad.Length, lstm.upward.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < wLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardWGrad[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            int bLen = lstm.upward.Bias.Length;

            Assert.AreEqual(cupwardbGrad.Length, lstm.upward.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < bLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardbGrad[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            //2周目
            Variable <Real> cX2  = new Variable <Real>(Real.ToBaseNdArray(input2));
            Variable <Real> cY21 = cLinear1.Forward(cX2);
            Variable <Real> cY22 = cLstm.Forward(cY21);
            Variable <Real> cY23 = cLinear2.Forward(cY22);
            Variable <Real> cT2  = new Variable <Real>(Real.ToBaseNdArray(teach2));

            Variable <Real> cLoss2 = new NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real>().Forward(cY23, cT2);

            //KelpNet
            NdArray x2  = new NdArray(Real.ToRealArray(input2), new[] { 1 }, 5);
            NdArray y21 = linear1.Forward(x2)[0];
            NdArray y22 = lstm.Forward(y21)[0];
            NdArray y23 = linear2.Forward(y22)[0];
            NdArray t2  = new NdArray(Real.ToRealArray(teach2), new[] { 1 }, 5);

            NdArray loss2 = new KelpNet.MeanSquaredError().Evaluate(y23, t2);

            Assert.AreEqual(cLoss2.Data[0], loss2.Data[0], delta);

            //Backwardを実行
            cLoss2.Backward();
            y23.Backward();


            Real[] cYdata21 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cY21.Data);
            Real[] cYdata22 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cY22.Data);
            Real[] cYdata23 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cY23.Data);
            Real[] cXgrad2  = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cX2.Grad);

            Real[] cupwardWGrad2 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cLstm.upward.W.Grad);
            Real[] cupwardbGrad2 = (Real[])cLstm.upward.b.Grad;
            Real[] clateralWGrad = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cLstm.lateral.W.Grad);

            //y21
            Assert.AreEqual(cYdata21.Length, y21.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cYdata21.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cYdata21[i], y21.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y22
            Assert.AreEqual(cYdata22.Length, y22.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cYdata22.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cYdata22[i], y22.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y23
            Assert.AreEqual(cYdata23.Length, y23.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cYdata23.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cYdata23[i], y23.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //x.Grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad2.Length, x2.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cXgrad2.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad2[i], x2.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //経由が多くかなり誤差が大きい為
            delta = 1.0;

            Real[] cWgrad22 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cLinear2.W.Grad);
            Real[] cbgrad22 = (Real[])cLinear2.b.Grad;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad22.Length, linear2.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad22[i], linear2.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad22.Length, linear2.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad22[i], linear2.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            delta = 2.0;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(clateralWGrad.Length, lstm.lateral.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < clateralWGrad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(clateralWGrad[i + wLen * 0], lstm.lateral.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            for (int i = 0; i < wLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardWGrad2[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            for (int i = 0; i < bLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardbGrad2[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            delta = 20.0;

            Real[] cWgrad21 = Real.ToRealArray((Real[, ])cLinear1.W.Grad);
            Real[] cbgrad21 = (Real[])cLinear1.b.Grad;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad21.Length, linear1.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad21[i], linear1.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad21.Length, linear1.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad21[i], linear1.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }
        }
Exemple #4
0
        public void RnnLSTMRandomTest()
        {
            Python.Initialize();
            Chainer.Initialize();

            Real[,] input = { { 1.0f }, { 3.0f }, { 5.0f }, { 7.0f }, { 9.0f } };
            Real[,] teach = { { 3.0f }, { 5.0f }, { 7.0f }, { 9.0f }, { 11.0f } };

            Real[,] input2 = { { 3.0f }, { 5.0f }, { 7.0f }, { 9.0f }, { 11.0f } };
            Real[,] teach2 = { { 5.0f }, { 7.0f }, { 9.0f }, { 11.0f }, { 13.0f } };

            int outputCount = 1;
            int inputCount  = 1;
            int hiddenCount = 2;

            Real[,] upwardInit      = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, ]>(hiddenCount, hiddenCount);
            Real[,] lateralInit     = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, ]>(hiddenCount, hiddenCount);
            Real[,,] biasInit       = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, , ]>(1, hiddenCount, 1);
            Real[,,] forgetBiasInit = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, , ]>(1, hiddenCount, 1);

            //Chainer
            Real[,] w1 = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, ]>(hiddenCount, inputCount);
            Real[] b1 = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[]>(hiddenCount);

            //Chainer
            Linear <Real> cLinear1 = new Linear <Real>(inputCount, hiddenCount, false, w1, b1);

            NChainer.LSTM <Real> cLstm = new NChainer.LSTM <Real>(hiddenCount, hiddenCount, lateralInit, upwardInit, biasInit, forgetBiasInit);

            Real[,] w2 = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[, ]>(outputCount, hiddenCount);
            Real[]        b2       = Initializer.GetRandomValues <Real[]>(outputCount);
            Linear <Real> cLinear2 = new Linear <Real>(hiddenCount, outputCount, false, w2, b2);

            Variable <Real> cX1  = new Variable <Real>(input);
            Variable <Real> cY11 = cLinear1.Forward(cX1);
            Variable <Real> cY12 = cLstm.Forward(cY11);
            Variable <Real> cY13 = cLinear2.Forward(cY12);
            Variable <Real> cT   = new Variable <Real>(teach);

            Variable <Real> cLoss = new NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real>().Forward(cY13, cT);

            cLoss.Backward();


            //KelpNet
            CL.Linear <Real> linear1 = new CL.Linear <Real>(inputCount, hiddenCount, false, w1, b1);
            LSTM <Real>      lstm    = new LSTM <Real>(hiddenCount, hiddenCount, lateralInit, upwardInit, biasInit, forgetBiasInit);

            CL.Linear <Real> linear2 = new CL.Linear <Real>(hiddenCount, outputCount, false, w2, b2);

            NdArray <Real> x1  = new NdArray <Real>(input, asBatch: true);
            NdArray <Real> y11 = linear1.Forward(x1)[0];
            NdArray <Real> y12 = lstm.Forward(y11)[0];
            NdArray <Real> y13 = linear2.Forward(y12)[0];
            NdArray <Real> t   = new NdArray <Real>(teach, asBatch: true);

            NdArray <Real> loss = new MeanSquaredError <Real>().Evaluate(y13, t);

            y13.Backward();

            Real[] cY11data = ((Real[, ])cY11.Data).Flatten();
            Real[] cY12data = ((Real[, ])cY12.Data).Flatten();
            Real[] cY13data = ((Real[, ])cY13.Data).Flatten();
            Real[] cXgrad   = ((Real[, ])cX1.Grad).Flatten();

            Real[] cupwardWGrad = ((Real[, ])cLstm.upward.W.Grad).Flatten();
            Real[] cupwardbGrad = (Real[])cLstm.upward.b.Grad;


            //許容範囲を設定
            Real delta = 0.00001f;

            //y11
            Assert.AreEqual(cY11data.Length, y11.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cY11data.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cY11data[i], y11.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y12
            Assert.AreEqual(cY12data.Length, y12.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cY12data.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cY12data[i], y12.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y13
            Assert.AreEqual(cY13data.Length, y13.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cY13data.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cY13data[i], y13.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //許容範囲を設定
            delta = 0.0001f;

            //loss
            Assert.AreEqual(cLoss.Data[0], loss.Data[0], delta);

            //x.Grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad.Length, x1.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cXgrad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad[i], x1.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            Real[] cWgrad11 = ((Real[, ])cLinear1.W.Grad).Flatten();
            Real[] cbgrad11 = (Real[])cLinear1.b.Grad;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad11.Length, linear1.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad11[i], linear1.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad11.Length, linear1.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad11[i], linear1.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            Real[] cWgrad12 = ((Real[, ])cLinear2.W.Grad).Flatten();
            Real[] cbgrad12 = (Real[])cLinear2.b.Grad;


            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad12.Length, linear2.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad12[i], linear2.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad12.Length, linear2.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad12[i], linear2.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //W.grad
            int wLen = lstm.upward.Weight.Grad.Length;

            Assert.AreEqual(cupwardWGrad.Length, lstm.upward.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < wLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardWGrad[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            int bLen = lstm.upward.Bias.Length;

            Assert.AreEqual(cupwardbGrad.Length, lstm.upward.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < bLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardbGrad[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            //2周目
            Variable <Real> cX2  = new Variable <Real>(input2);
            Variable <Real> cY21 = cLinear1.Forward(cX2);
            Variable <Real> cY22 = cLstm.Forward(cY21);
            Variable <Real> cY23 = cLinear2.Forward(cY22);
            Variable <Real> cT2  = new Variable <Real>(teach2);

            Variable <Real> cLoss2 = new NChainer.MeanSquaredError <Real>().Forward(cY23, cT2);

            //KelpNet
            NdArray <Real> x2  = new NdArray <Real>(input2, asBatch: true);
            NdArray <Real> y21 = linear1.Forward(x2)[0];
            NdArray <Real> y22 = lstm.Forward(y21)[0];
            NdArray <Real> y23 = linear2.Forward(y22)[0];
            NdArray <Real> t2  = new NdArray <Real>(teach2, asBatch: true);

            NdArray <Real> loss2 = new MeanSquaredError <Real>().Evaluate(y23, t2);

            Assert.AreEqual(cLoss2.Data[0], loss2.Data[0], delta);

            //Backwardを実行
            cLoss2.Backward();
            y23.Backward();


            Real[] cYdata21 = ((Real[, ])cY21.Data).Flatten();
            Real[] cYdata22 = ((Real[, ])cY22.Data).Flatten();
            Real[] cYdata23 = ((Real[, ])cY23.Data).Flatten();
            Real[] cXgrad2  = ((Real[, ])cX2.Grad).Flatten();

            Real[] cupwardWGrad2 = ((Real[, ])cLstm.upward.W.Grad).Flatten();
            Real[] cupwardbGrad2 = (Real[])cLstm.upward.b.Grad;
            Real[] clateralWGrad = ((Real[, ])cLstm.lateral.W.Grad).Flatten();

            //y21
            Assert.AreEqual(cYdata21.Length, y21.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cYdata21.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cYdata21[i], y21.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y22
            Assert.AreEqual(cYdata22.Length, y22.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cYdata22.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cYdata22[i], y22.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //y23
            Assert.AreEqual(cYdata23.Length, y23.Data.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cYdata23.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cYdata23[i], y23.Data[i], delta);
            }

            //x.Grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad2.Length, x2.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < cXgrad2.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cXgrad2[i], x2.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //経由が多くかなり誤差が大きい為
            delta = 1.0f;

            Real[] cWgrad22 = ((Real[, ])cLinear2.W.Grad).Flatten();
            Real[] cbgrad22 = (Real[])cLinear2.b.Grad;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad22.Length, linear2.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad22[i], linear2.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad22.Length, linear2.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear2.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad22[i], linear2.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            delta = 2.0f;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(clateralWGrad.Length, lstm.lateral.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < clateralWGrad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(clateralWGrad[i + wLen * 0], lstm.lateral.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            for (int i = 0; i < wLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardWGrad2[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            for (int i = 0; i < bLen; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cupwardbGrad2[i + wLen * 0], lstm.upward.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }


            delta = 20.0f;

            Real[] cWgrad21 = ((Real[, ])cLinear1.W.Grad).Flatten();
            Real[] cbgrad21 = (Real[])cLinear1.b.Grad;

            //W.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad21.Length, linear1.Weight.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Weight.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cWgrad21[i], linear1.Weight.Grad[i], delta);
            }

            //b.grad
            Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad21.Length, linear1.Bias.Grad.Length);
            for (int i = 0; i < linear1.Bias.Grad.Length; i++)
            {
                Assert.AreEqual(cbgrad21[i], linear1.Bias.Grad[i], delta);
            }
        }